Was Debt A Key Factor Behind Social Inequality in the Early Cities of Mesopotamia And the Indus civilization ?

 David Graeber, an American anthropologist, says that creditors must own the “means to specify” what they are owed to convert debts into everlasting inequalities. In his book “Debt: the first 5,000 years”, David Graeber contends that everlasting economic inequalities arise when the payment of certain debts that could possibly be paid back are permanently anticipated. Which creating a greedy social relationship that extracts capital from borrowers and credits it with creditors. The establishment of such disparities is liable on materializing info about exchange relations. It needs creditors to own the “means to specify” what they are owed and the ability to force assembly through violence.

Was Debt A Key Factor Behind Social Inequality in the Early Cities of Mesopotamia And the Indus civilization?
Photo by Juan ignacio Tapia on Unsplash (Only for picture depiction purpose)

The variations in the technologies used to postulate can transform social relations. An effective research is required to find out the “means of specification.” Seals and Sealings are usually considered as the means of transection in Indus and Mesopotamian civilizations. These things from the oldest South Asian cities and the Near East are a criterion for comparing changes in specification means.

Photo by Mihrican Atilla on Unsplash

In his book “The Gift”, Marcel Mauss describe the debt. The ‘debt’ is the most malicious kind of responsibility. If unfulfilled, it can consequence in slavery.


Adam S. Green of McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research at University of Cambridge study Mesopotamian seals and sealings. In Mesopotamian cities, an administrative ruling class apprehended power. On the Other side, urbanism flourished under comparatively egalitarian circumstances at the Indus civilization.

Photo by Noman Bukhari on Unsplash

Seals and sealings did not unavoidably exacerbate inequality. It was only after periods of control by exclusionary and often fierce political institutes that the governing class used the means of specification to create interest bearing debt in Mesopotamia. It was a system of “extractive reciprocity” that relocated value to creditors in a continuing community relationship.

In the Indus valley civilization, there was no such governing class, the sealings and seals continued to be eagerly accessible and extensively circulated. This process sustained the “balanced reciprocity” in escalating urban surroundings.

Photo by Arthur Yeti on Unsplash

Basically, the Seals were inscribed with descriptions and images that could be imitative by pressing seals into clay. This process helps in generating sealings for vessels and constructions. The technology’s use produces glyptic datasets encompassed of seals and the sealings. Sealings permitted folks to materialize evidence about the instant they were formed. It could be aided numerous religious, talkative, conceptual and representational purposes.

They possibly permitted their handlers to change what were possibly exclusive and surfaced social interactions into graphical depictions that were extremely systematized and conventionalized. This capability made them particularly significant to exchange as they permitted people to record the situations of specific material dealings. The seal and sealings introduced conspicuously in the Civilizations of Mesopotamia, Iran, Anatolia, Egypt, and South Asia by 3rd millennium B.C. in complex forms.

Photo by mostafa meraji on Unsplash

In Mesopotamian region, commanding exclusionary politically aware establishments, i.e., temples and palaces used seals and sealings as their economic activities and administrative practices. The materialization of taxes and payments strategies permitted decision-making governing class to take away wealth from their lower social classes. These practices were often including a amalgamation of quantification and ferocity. Seals and sealings are seen as administrative technologies, but they really created in the Neolithic age. A long before the exclusionary politically aware and financial establishments of the Bronze era or Stage of development occurred. In South Asia, the Indus age evolution established a significant, strengthened and dedicated Bronze Age economy in the nonappearance of a ruling hierarchy.

Photo by Hulki Okan Tabak on Unsplash

Exercising regulator over info can fetch about new exchange forms. They can in turn fundamentally change the dispersal of supremacy and capital However, materializing information can enable people to equalize the distribution of capital just as easily as it can substitute inequalities.

The disparities in the means of specification can yield permanent inequalities. They can also assistance delay the achievement of transactions until sensible conditions succeed.

Know the Past Places:

1. Mesopotamia: It is the zone between the tow rivers i.e., Euphrates and Tigris rivers. It is located north or northwest of the Baghdad. Arabs calls it Al-Jazīrah (“The Island”). The Babylonia is located in its south.

2. Indus: The areas of most of modern Islamic republic of Pakistan, North-western India, and east Afghanistan.

Note: 1. Theculturemag is acts as a bridge between researchers and public. We tell the people about new researches and new knowing about human past and its culture.

Read original article Debt and inequality: Comparing the “means of specification” in the early cities of Mesopotamia and the Indus civilization on Journal of Anthropological Archaeology.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *